Fairport Harbor Lighthouse in Haunted Ohio

The Fairport Harbor Lighthouse, situated in Fairport Harbor, Ohio, has stood as a historic landmark since its construction in 1871. Originally serving as an active lighthouse, it provided guidance and safety to mariners navigating Lake Erie. However, in 1925, the light was decommissioned and subsequently replaced by the Fairport Harbor West Breakwater Light. Ownership of the lighthouse was transferred to the town in 1945 after the Coast Guard relinquished control. Today, the Fairport Harbor Lighthouse has been transformed into a popular tourist destination, with the keeper’s house serving as a museum and gift shop, offering visitors a chance to explore the lighthouse’s rich history.

Amongst the tales surrounding the Fairport Harbor Lighthouse, one legend stands out: the ghostly presence of a cat said to roam the property. Many guests have reported experiencing the sensation of a cat rubbing against their legs as they stroll around the grounds. Some have even claimed to witness the feline darting across the kitchen area. Visitors have also shared accounts of feeling a cat jump onto the bed within the keeper’s house. According to the story, the first lightkeeper’s wife, Mary Babcock, cherished a beloved gray cat that provided her companionship during her later years. As she fell ill, the cats became her constant companions, spending days together in bed. Following Mary’s passing, the cat mysteriously disappeared. Years later, during renovations, contractors made a macabre discovery—a mummified cat hidden in a crawl space beneath the house. Could this feline remains belong to Mary’s cherished cat?

While the authenticity of the ghost cat’s presence cannot be verified, the story adds a layer of intrigue to the Fairport Harbor Lighthouse’s history. Visitors who encounter the spectral feline or feel its ethereal touch are reminded of the enduring bond between Mary and her feline companions, leaving them to wonder if the presence of this ghostly cat serves as a testament to the enduring love and loyalty that transcends the boundaries of life and death.

Sources:
1. “Fairport Harbor Lighthouse Marine Museum” – Lake County Historical Society
2. “Fairport Harbor West Breakwater Lighthouse” – Ohio Exploration Society