Nelsen’s Hall: Embracing the Haunting Legacy of a Historic Tavern
Nelsen’s Hall, nestled on Washington Island, has been a cherished establishment since its opening in 1899 by Danish immigrant Tom Nelsen. With a rich history that includes operating as a bar during the prohibition era by cleverly obtaining a pharmaceutical license to dispense bitters, this iconic venue has evolved over the years. From an ice cream parlor and movie theater to a dentist office and pharmacy, Nelsen’s Hall has witnessed the passage of time and remains a beloved landmark on the island. Today, known as Nelsen’s Hall and Bitters Pub, it continues to serve its patrons with potent shots of bitters under the ownership of Robin Ditello. However, along with its historical charm, the tavern is believed to harbor a ghostly presence that adds to its allure and intrigue.
The History of Nelsen’s Hall
Nelsen’s Hall holds a significant place in the history of Washington Island, Wisconsin. Established by Tom Nelsen, an industrious Danish immigrant, the tavern weathered the storm of prohibition through a clever workaround. By obtaining a pharmaceutical license to dispense bitters, Nelsen ensured that his bar remained operational, allowing patrons to indulge in libations during a time of nationwide alcohol prohibition.
Throughout its storied past, Nelsen’s Hall underwent transformations, serving the community in various capacities. From a bustling ice cream parlor where islanders would gather for sweet treats to a movie theater offering entertainment and a place of respite, the hall became a central hub for the island’s social activities. It also housed a dentist’s office and a pharmacy, catering to the diverse needs of the local residents.
Today, under the ownership of Robin Ditello, Nelsen’s Hall remains a cherished establishment, combining its historical charm with the continuation of the tradition of serving potent shots of bitters to visitors and locals alike.
Is Nelsen’s Hall Haunted?
Nelsen’s Hall is no stranger to whispers of paranormal activity, as the ghostly presence of Tom Nelsen himself is said to linger within its walls. Having passed away at the age of ninety in an upstairs room, Nelsen’s spirit is believed to have developed a deep attachment to his beloved establishment. Robin Ditello, the current owner, openly acknowledges the presence of the ghost and welcomes guests to embrace the haunted legacy of Nelsen’s Hall.
Visitors to the tavern have reported eerie occurrences that suggest the supernatural influence of Tom Nelsen’s spirit. Mysterious footsteps echo through the hallways, and doors inexplicably close without any apparent cause. On occasion, the radio station spontaneously changes, captivating those present with its unexplained manipulation. Women have shared encounters with Nelsen’s ghost near the bathroom, experiencing the sensation of something brushing against the back of their necks. This behavior seemingly reflects Nelsen’s reputation as a ladies’ man, a characteristic that appears to have transcended into the realm of the afterlife.
It is important to note that Nelsen’s ghostly presence is not malevolent. On the contrary, Robin Ditello perceives it as a sign of approval from the departed Nelsen, a subtle reassurance that she is upholding the legacy of the tavern with competence and dedication.
Nelsen’s Hall stands as a testament to the enduring allure of history and the lingering echoes of the past. By embracing its haunted reputation, this cherished tavern on Washington Island continues to captivate visitors seeking an experience that intertwines tradition, spirits—both ghostly and distilled—and the timeless charm of a bygone era.
Address: 1201 Main Rd, Washington, WI 54246
Sources:
1. WisDells. “Nelsen’s Hall & Bitters Pub.” https://www.wisdells.com/
2. The Daily Meal. https://www.thedailymeal.com/drink/best-dive-bar-every-state-gallery
Leave a Reply