The Haunted Story Inn in Nashville Indiana

The Haunted Legends of The Story Inn: Unveiling the Blue Lady’s Mystery

Nestled in the historic logging town of Story, Indiana, The Story Inn stands as a testament to the past. Established in the mid-19th century by Dr. George Story, the town flourished with various amenities and establishments. However, the Great Depression led to the departure of most residents, leaving behind a charming and preserved slice of history. The Story Inn, founded by new owners after the town’s decline, has become renowned not only for its rustic charm but also for its association with paranormal activity. This article delves into the captivating history of The Story Inn and explores the mysterious presence of the “Blue Lady” who is said to haunt its premises.

The History of the Story Inn

The town of Story was founded in 1851 by Dr. George Story, a medical doctor with a vision for a thriving community. At its peak, the town boasted a post office, sawmill, schoolhouse, church, slaughterhouse, blacksmith forge, and two general stores. However, the Great Depression took its toll on Story, and most of its residents sought opportunities elsewhere, leaving the town in a state of decline.

In the aftermath of the Great Depression, the town and its historic buildings caught the attention of two individuals from Bloomingdale, who saw the potential in preserving the town’s unique character. They purchased the town and transformed it into The Story Inn, ensuring that the original charm remained intact. The current owner, Rick Hofstetter, has taken up the mantle of preserving Indiana’s historic landmarks, including The Story Inn.

Is the Story Inn Haunted?

When Rick Hofstetter took over The Story Inn, he was already aware of the inn’s haunted reputation. However, as a skeptic, he approached the claims with skepticism. Upon his arrival, he discovered that each guest room had its own visitors book, which had become a tradition. These books contained stories from guests about their experiences with paranormal activity.

Among the many reported encounters, one room situated directly above the inn’s restaurant garnered the most attention. Guests and staff frequently shared stories about the presence of the “Blue Lady.” Believed to be the spirit of Dr. George Story’s deceased wife, she often made her presence known in what was known as the inn’s “gardening room.”

The apparition earned the moniker “Blue Lady” due to the tales that she would appear when a blue light was placed in the room. However, there are also accounts of her manifesting without any external stimuli. Descriptions of the Blue Lady often include references to her striking blue eyes, and she is known to leave behind blue items in her wake.

The Story Inn has become a hotspot for paranormal enthusiasts and curious visitors seeking a glimpse into the supernatural. Guests and staff have reported experiencing unexplained phenomena, including cold spots, objects moving on their own, and a palpable sense of presence. The Blue Lady remains an enigmatic figure, captivating the imagination of those who encounter her or hear the tales passed down through generations.

The Story Inn, with its rich history and connection to the past, has become an intriguing destination for both history enthusiasts and those fascinated by the paranormal. The presence of the Blue Lady, believed to be the spirit of Dr. George Story’s wife, adds an air of mystery to the inn. As visitors and staff share their encounters and experiences, the legend of the Blue Lady continues to grow, drawing curious individuals to The Story Inn in search of answers to the spectral enigma that surrounds this historic establishment.